Creighton vs Butler Predictions, NCAAB Picks Jan 11: Bet Bluejays (-2) ATS
- Creighton (-12) is our top pick for January 11.
- We like the Creighton vs Butler game to go under 145.
- Bet $200 on College Basketball Games & Get a $450 Risk-Free Bonus on your first-time deposit!



The Butler Bulldogs are still looking for their first Big East win of the season. Getting it against visiting Creighton is not the easiest of tasks. Our Creighton vs Butler betting lines have Creighton favored by two points.
When looking at futures, Creighton is fourth at +1000 in our odds to win the Big East title while Butler is seventh at +17500 in the championship odds.
Check out our best Creighton vs Butler expert picks ahead.
Creighton vs Butler Game Information
- Game: Creighton (9-6, 2-2 Big East) vs Butler (7-9, 0-5)
- Date/Time: Saturday, Jan. 11, noon ET
- Location: Hinkle Fieldhouse, Indianapolis, IN
- Creighton vs Butler Live Stream: Fubo.tv
Find Creighton vs Butler betting trends here.
2 Creighton vs Butler Bets: ATS, Over/Under Picks
1. Creighton (-2)
Neither of these teams is exactly loaded with confidence right now.
Creighton is 1-1 both outright and against the spread as a double-digit favorite this season. Creighton has won its last six Big East games when favored by at least 10 points, covering the spread in four of them.
Work before hitting the road #GoJays pic.twitter.com/vPQf1mJzVE
— Creighton Men’s Basketball (@BluejayMBB) January 9, 2025
Creighton has covered in four of its last five games and is 10-3 ATS in its last 13 Big East games. Butler is 4-11 as a college basketball pick against the spread in its last 15 games in January. Going with Creighton to win outright is one way to proceed, but we’ll take the Bluehays to cover as the 2-point favorite.
2. Creighton vs Butler Under 145 (-105)
The last five times that our NCAAB betting odds listed Creighton as the road favorite, the game landed under the total by nearly eight points. That includes the most recent matchup with Butler.
Both Creighton and Butler are outside the top 50 in offensive efficiency according to the Pomeroy basketball database. It’s not all bad news as Butler’s Andre Screen recently scored his 1000th career point.
1000 career points for ANDRE SCREEN pic.twitter.com/9vwkg9gd4g
— Butler Basketball (@ButlerMBB) January 9, 2025
Creighton opened Big East play by scoring just 57 points in a loss at Georgetown before bouncing back with an 86-point effort as the Bluejays nipped St. John’s 57-56. The offense was slightly better the last time out with 71 points in a loss at Marquette. However, Creighton’s offense is still a work in progress.
It is still in better shape than Butler’s offense with the Bulldogs scoring 65, 62 and 65 in their first three games in 2025. Keep that in mind when making college basketball picks today.
Bet On Creighton vs Butler Under 145 (-105)
Creighton vs Butler Prediction
Creighton 74, Butler 69
Odds and information are accurate at the time of writing. Please check with official sources for the latest updates before placing any bets
Questions Of The Day
Which team has a better record against the spread this season, Creighton or Butler?
Butler is 8-8 and Creighton is 6-7-2 against the spread this season.
What happened the last time that Creighton faced Butler?
Favored Creighton trailed at halftime in the most recent matchup but outscored Butler 45-22 in the second half to win 79-55.