2025 MLB Cy Young Predictions and Odds: AL, NL 6 Best Bets
- Pittsburgh’s Paul Skenes is a heavy favorite in the NL Cy Young Award odds
- Don’t bet against a repeat by Detroit’s Tarik Skubal
- Make bank with our top MLB picks! Join with our promo code HUDDLE125.
The Cy Young Award is baseball’s ultimate flex for pitchers. It’s where velocity meets virtuosity, and every nasty slider counts. For 2025, we’ve got chalk picks, value MLB predictions and wild dark horses lined up. Let’s explore six names — three from each league — that could dominate the mound this year.
NL Cy Young Winner Odds
- Paul Skenes +250
- Zack Wheeler +750
- Chris Sale +750
- Blake Snell +1200
- Corbin Burnes +1200
- Dylan Cease +1600
- Tyler Glasnow +1800
- Spencer Strider +1800
- Michael King +2200
- Hunter Greene +2200
- Sandy Alcantara +2200
- Yoshinobu Yamamoto +2500
- Logan Webb +2500
- Freddy Peralta +2800
- Kodai Senga +2800
- Zac Gallen +3000
- Sonny Gray +3000
- Shota Imanaga +3000
- Shohei Ohtani +3000
3 Top NL Cy Young Picks
1. NL Cy Young Favorite: Paul Skenes (+250)
Pittsburgh Pirates rookie Paul Skenes showed up in 2024, threw gas and left hitters frozen. A 1.96 ERA, Rookie of the Year honors, and 170 Ks in just 133 innings — yeah, that’s Cy Young material.
This kid’s second season might be even better, especially if the Pirates let him stretch his innings. His fastball-slider combo is MLB’s version of a cheat code, and his consistency is jaw-dropping. At +250 MLB odds, Skenes is the safe bet online if you’re looking for dominance with a side of youth.
Just throwing it out there that Paul Skenes pitches in 41 days.
No particular reason at all. pic.twitter.com/8uDNoPB5sV
— Platinum Ke’Bryan (@PlatinumKey13) January 12, 2025
2. NL Cy Young Value Pick: Zack Wheeler (+750)
Philadelphia’s Zack Wheeler has been the bridesmaid of the Cy Young race twice, and 2025 might finally be his turn to toss the bouquet and make MLB news. With a 2.57 ERA and NL-best 0.96 WHIP in 2024, Wheeler was a model of elite efficiency for the Phillies.
He’s a strikeout artist with incredible durability, logging 200 innings like it’s no big deal. At +750 in MLB futures odds, Wheeler offers both value and reliability — perfect for bettors who like steady hands over flash-in-the-pan picks.
3. NL Cy Young Dark Horse: Yoshinobu Yamamoto (+2500)
Yoshinobu Yamamoto didn’t have the flashiest rookie year with the Los Angeles Dodgers, but his late-season surge and postseason dominance turned heads. A 3.00 ERA and 105 Ks over 90 innings don’t scream Cy Young, but his stuff does.
The Japanese import’s pinpoint control and deceptive breaking pitches make him a dangerous opponent. If Yamamoto gets a full workload in 2025 and builds on his playoff momentum, those +2500 odds could become a massive payday.
MLB 2025 American League Cy Young Odds
- Tarik Skubal +500
- Garrett Crochet +500
- Cole Ragans +700
- Jacob deGrom +500
- Gerrit Cole +1600
- Logan Gilbert +1200
- Framber Valdez +1600
- Pablo Lopez +1600
- Grayson Rodriguez +1600
- Shane McClanahan +1600
- George Kirby +2500
- Max Fried +2500
- Hunter Brown +2500
- Luis Castillo +2800
- Kevin Gausman +2800
3 Top AL Cy Young Picks
1. AL Cy Young Favorite: Tarik Skubal (+500)
Tarik Skubal had the kind of 2024 season that makes hitters question their career choices. A 2.34 ERA, 244 punchouts and a WHIP barely above 0.90? Nasty. Skubal brought the heat and finesse, anchoring Detroit’s rotation during a surprise playoff push.
His command is sharper than a brand-new cleat, and with that fastball-changeup combo, batters are in for another miserable year. Add in a resurgent Tigers lineup, and Skubal’s online betting path to back-to-back Cy Youngs looks clearer than a sunny day at Comerica.
Michigan State Basketball is 1-0 with Tarik Skubal in the Breslin Center.
True difference maker🔥 pic.twitter.com/x65Qh4yADW
— Jax (@TheDETSpartan) January 19, 2025
2. AL Cy Young Value Pick: Cole Ragans (+700)
Cole Ragans quietly became Kansas City’s lefty king in 2024, showing that a good trade can flip the script. Ragans was a nightmare for opposing lineups with a 3.14 ERA, 29% strikeout rate, and a fastball that defies logic and almost physics.
His home-road splits per MLB stats? Insanely consistent, proving he’s not just a hometown hero. If Ragans can trim his walks and sustain his whiff rates, he might just take home the hardware. Plus, who doesn’t love rooting for a guy who made a reliever-to-starter transition look this seamless?
3. AL Cy Young Dark Horse: Shane McClanahan (+1600)
Shane McClanahan’s biggest challenge has been staying healthy. But when he’s on, the Tampa Bays Rays’ ace delivers filth like a pitcher possessed. His career 2.85 ERA and 10+ K/9 prove his stuff belongs in the Cy Young conversation.
Tampa Bay’s roster isn’t inspiring confidence, but McClanahan’s fastball-slider combo is terrifying enough to steal wins. If he stays off the IL and leans into his ace potential, those +1600 odds for MLB picks could feel like stealing.
Odds and information are accurate at the time of writing. Please check with official sources for the latest updates before placing any bets.
Question of the Day
Who won the 2024 Cy Young Awards?
Tarik Skubal won the AL Cy Young while Chris Sale won the AL trophy.
