Skip to content

A Bronx Tale of the Tape: Yankees’ Judge, Soto Atop AL MVP Odds

When we look back into MLB history and think about the most dangerous offensive teammates, several duos come to mind. Ken Griffey Jr and Alex Rodriguez. Mark McGwire and Jose Canseco. Chipper Jones and Andruw Jones. Roger Maris and Mickey Mantle are good examples.

In 2024, we’re witnessing the birth of a new chapter in MLB history with Aaron Judge and Juan Soto. It’s still relatively early on in the season, but the two sluggers from the Bronx have been rewriting the record books and their performances echoing those of the greats who came before them.

A Bronx Tale of the Tape: Yankees’ Judge, Soto Atop AL MVP Odds
Aaron Judge #99 | Brandon Vallance/Getty Images/AFP

As of Monday morning, Judge leads the race with +120 MLB odds to win the American League MVP, with Soto a close second at +400. Mind you, these two aren’t the only ones in the race, with Bobby Witt Jr. also +400, but today, I just want to focus on these two teammates and which is a better bet online to hoist the hardware come October.


Aaron Judge +120 to win MVP

After starting the season slow, the 2022 AL MVP, Aaron Judge, became a juggernaut as spring gave way to summer. Picture this: Judge strolling up to the plate, cracking his knuckles and then casually obliterating baseballs into orbit. That’s essentially what he did in May.

Let’s talk numbers because they’re absolutely bonkers. Judge slashed .361/.479/.918 with 14 home runs and 27 RBIs in May alone. Yes, you read that right — 14 homers and a slugging percentage that looks like a typo. He single-handedly propelled the Yankees to the top of the AL East, making opposing pitchers question their life choices.

The Yankees now sit pretty at an AL-best 46-21, 2.5 games ahead of the Baltimore Orioles, with an 8-2 record in their last 10 games.

Judge’s May performance is one for the history books. How historic? Well, he’s the first player in Yankees’ history and only the second in MLB history to hit 14 home runs and 12 doubles in a calendar month. These numbers scream MVP louder than a Bronx cheer.

Despite a sluggish start, Judge’s current .538 batting average over his last eight games, complete with 14 hits, 4 home runs, 14 RBIs and 11 runs scored, paints a picture of a man on a mission. A mission to win his second MVP award. If he continues at this torrid pace, there’s no doubt he’ll collect more hardware by the end of the season.

Judge is not just playing baseball, he’s putting on a masterclass. It’s like he’s in a video game, and someone forgot to turn off the cheat codes. So, to all pitchers out there: Good luck because this guy is out here making baseballs fear for their lives.



Juan Soto (+400) Top Threat to Judge in MVP Race

Juan Soto, New York’s prized offseason acquisition, has been nothing short of a sensation this season. His consistent prowess at the plate has cemented his status as one of MLB’s elite hitters and set the stage for a potential MVP showdown with teammate Judge.

Imagine a Yankees duo finishing 1-2 in MVP balloting, a feat achieved only seven times before. This year, Soto and Judge could make it the eighth.

Soto’s numbers are dazzling. Slashing .318/.424/.603 with 17 home runs and 53 RBIs, he’s on a tear that’s making pitchers everywhere lose sleep. This three-time All-Star and four-time Silver Slugger is not just putting up impressive individual numbers, but also playing a crucial role in the team’s success. His consistent hitting and ability to drive in runs have been instrumental in the Yankees’ strong performance this season.

Soto, acquired from San Diego in the offseason, recently had one of his most clutch moments in a Yankees uniform. He hit a go-ahead, two-run homer in the ninth inning off Camilo Doval, who just happened to be tied for the National League lead in saves last season. Talk about rising to the occasion! Oh, and it was his second bomb of the game for those keeping track.

Despite all this, Soto ranks second in MVP talks behind Judge, which speaks volumes about how otherworldly Judge has been playing. Yet, it’s not a knock on Soto. If anything, it’s a testament to his greatness that a player as hot as prime Barry Bonds might finish second in MVP voting. Soto’s 4.1 WAR this season already surpasses his 2022 total of 3.6, a “down year” for him.

While Soto hasn’t had a month as blistering as Judge’s May, his steady production has been vital. He’s been holding down the fort, batting consistently and keeping the Yankees in contention even when Judge struggled early on. Soto has shown his ability to rise to the occasion, often outperforming Judge and contributing significantly to the team’s success.

If these two continue their torrid pace, we’ll be reminiscing about 1961 when Yankees legends Roger Maris and Mickey Mantle battled it out for AL MVP while leading the team to their 19th World Series title.

A 1-2 finish by Judge and Soto would be a testament to their greatness and a significant milestone in the Yankees’ history. So, whether it’s Soto’s steady hammering or Judge’s explosive power, Yankees fans have a lot to cheer — and pitchers everywhere have plenty to fear.



Odds and information are accurate at the time of writing. Please check with official sources for the latest updates before placing any bets.


Questions of the Day

Who has won the most MVP awards in MLB history?

Barry Bonds has had the most MVP awards, with seven throughout his career.

Did you find this article interesting?

Comments (0)