Mets vs Yankees Same Game Parlay Picks, Friday, 5/16

Oscar Diaz

· May 16 - 3 minutes read

We’re taking the game hitting Under 9 total runs.
Go with Aaron Judge to hit 1+ home runs (+150).
Make bank with our 2025 MLB Season picks! Join with our promo code HUDDLE125.

Mets vs Yankees SGP Picks Today, May 16, 2025

Parlay Picks

Odds

Mets vs Yankees Under

Aaron Judge to Hit 1+ Home Runs

Francisco Lindor Over 1.5 Total Bases From Hits

Bet These Parlay Picks at BetUS Sportsbook!

Mets vs Yankees Same Game Parlay Picks, Friday, 5/16 — New York Yankees designated hitter Aaron Judge (99) | John Froschauer-Imagn Images

This Subway Series matchup is a showdown between two of MLB’s best of both worlds. The Yankees lead the league in runs per game, slugging, and OBP, while the Mets boast the No. 1 ERA and lowest opponent HR rate.

Despite both teams being top contenders in the MLB futures odds, this one projects as a low-scoring grinder. Based on MLB odds and team trends, I’m leaning toward the Bronx to come out on top of a low-scoring Big Apple battle.

Top 3 Mets vs Yankees Parlay Picks

1. Mets vs Yankees Under 9 Runs

I wanted to take the MLB moneyline here, but realized the total provided better value. The Yankees lead MLB in runs per game, but both teams are in the top three in opponent batting average and run prevention. The Mets have the league’s best ERA, and the Yankees hold opponents under 4 runs per game. This Subway Series will likely lean under if you want to make a short-term MLB futures bet on the weekend games.

Bet on Mets vs Yankees Under 9Runs

2. Aaron Judge to Hit 1+ Home Runs (+150)

Let me fill you in if you haven’t been reading the MLB news. Judge is on a tear — 15 homers with a .782 SLG and 40 runs scored in just 165 at-bats. He’s leading the league in AVG, HR< RBI, and OPS. It’s actually absurd at this point how hot he is. The Mets’ pitching has been elite, but Judge has hit even the best arms this season. If anyone’s going deep in this game, it’s him. I’m locking this in as one of my favorite MLB prop picks.

ALL RISE

Aaron Judge regains the Major League home run lead with No. 15! pic.twitter.com/yQX0Yt3Bn3

— MLB (@MLB) May 14, 2025

Bet on Aaron Judge to Score 1+ Home Runs (+150)

3. Francisco Lindor Over 1.5 Total Bases From Hits (+117)

Lindor is hitting .297 with 9 home runs and has seen the ball well lately. With the Yankees’ pitching more vulnerable against MLB matchups with lefties, Lindor could sneak in a double or pair of singles to cash this. If he doesn’t get an extra base hit, he still has a fair shot to cash this prop with four multi-hit games in his last seven starts. It’s a solid look for anyone building MLB parlay bets today.

7/24/2024

Francisco Lindor leads the Mets to a blowout win against the Yankees, where he homered from BOTH sides of the plate 😳

METS-YANKEES THIS WEEKEND 👀😈 (@SleeperYankees)pic.twitter.com/qh9kzYclj2

— SleeperMets (@SleeperMets) May 15, 2025