NFL Player Props Picks Jaguars vs Colts on January 05: Taylor Best TD Bet
- Get the latest Jaguars vs Colts betting lines at BetUS.
- Jonathan Taylor could once again be the star running back of the week.
- Find my top Jaguars vs Colts NFL prop picks ahead.
There are some value NFL prop odds available for the Jacksonville Jaguars vs Indianapolis Colts game on Sunday afternoon, including running back Jonathan Taylor to score a touchdown.

Jaguars vs Colts Game Information
- Game: Jaguars (4-12) at Colts (7-9)
- Date/Time: Sunday, Jan. 5, 1 p.m. ET
- Location: Lucas Oil Stadium, Indianapolis, IN
- Jaguars vs Colts Live Stream: NFL Game Pass
Get Jaguars vs Colts betting tips here.
3 Jaguars vs Colts Prop Picks for Jan 5
1. Jonathan Taylor to Score TD
Taylor has been a beast for the Colts over the last two weeks, scoring five touchdowns, so we’re backing him to keep that form going on Sunday.
The Colts running back had been under pressure for his lack of production, but after scoring three touchdowns against the Titans and two last week against the Giants, the 25-year-old is back to his best.
Those games might have come against easy opposition, but that’s the case against the Jaguars. He’s not facing a tough team and he could take advantage by scoring a touchdown. He’s also a good chance to score the opening TD at better odds.
Our NFL player prop picks include Taylor to score a TD, and he’ll likely be the difference for the Colts.
Bet this Pick: Jonathan Taylor TD (-167)
Touchdown Profits! Bet $200, Get $450 Bonus on first time deposit.
2. Jags & Colts Over 1.5 Field Goals Made
Our NFL prop predictions have the Jaguars over 1½ field goals and the Colts over 1½, which can be combined for a same-game parlay.
We expect more field goals than touchdowns in this AFC South game, where neither team is making the playoffs, and that could result in the offense spluttering in the red zone, in particular the Jaguars.
We don’t see the road team scoring too many touchdowns, so as their recent history suggests, field goals are their best scoring option. They scored two field goals last week against the Titans, so there is no reason why they can’t match that number.
Anthony Richardson is even tapping out while on the sideline pic.twitter.com/XSYe5LamTN
— No Context Film Guy Network (@nocontextFGN) December 29, 2024
Per NFL news, the Colts are without their top quarterback Anthony Richardson, and although Joe Flacco is experienced, they often have to settle for a field goal.
The Colts over pays -159 and Jags over pays -118, so include them in the same online bet as a prop pick.
Bet this Pick: Jags and Colts Over 1½ Field Goals Each
3. Three Straight Scores – No
Our NFL Week 18 predictions have picked “No” for the three straight scores option, which pays +150.
We see this game being a back-and-forth contest, and the odds are too good to pass up. Per Jaguars vs Colts stats, there weren’t three straight scores for a team when Indy lost to the Giants 45-33 last week, and there is less chance of it happening against Jacksonville.
The Jaguars scored three consecutive times when beating Tennessee last week, but they won’t get the same offensive opportunities. Therefore, take the value odds for “No” which has a good chance of paying out bettors.
Bet This Pick: Three Straight Scores “No” (+150)
More Jaguars vs Colts Week 18 Bets and Picks
- Jaguars vs Colts Picks, Prediction and Odds for NFL Week 18, January 05
- Jaguars vs Colts Same Game Parlay for January 5: Fade Total TDs
Questions Of The Day
What are the moneyline odds in the Jaguars vs Colts game?
The Indianapolis Colts are -225 moneyline favorites to beat the Jacksonville Jaguars (+190) on Sunday.
Who won the most recent meeting between Jacksonville and Indianapolis?
The Jaguars won the most recent meeting 37-34 in 2024, but the Colts lead 27-20 in the all-time matchup.
Odds and information are accurate at the time of writing. Please check with official sources for the latest updates before placing any bets.