Skip to content

New York Giants 2024: Dark Horse or Disaster? Predictions After Barkley's Exit

The New York Giants are stepping into a new, uncertain era. With Saquon Barkley’s shocking departure to the rival Eagles, the team faces an identity crisis. Can Daniel Jones rise to the occasion and solidify his role as the franchise quarterback? Will the Giants’ revamped offense find its footing in the highly competitive NFC East?

Barkley’s exit leaves a gaping hole, but it also opens the door for a new, potentially revitalized team culture. The 2024 season promises to be a defining one for the Giants. Will they rise above the ashes or succumb to the pressure? We’re breaking down the schedule, their initial season odds and predicting what might be in store for the Giants.

Are the Giants a Trap Bet in 2024? Expert Analysis & Season Forecast

The Giants are looking to become a tempting proposition for bettors in 2024. With Barkley’s departure, oddsmakers have adjusted their expectations, potentially creating a value bet if long shots are your game. But is this a trap?

Can an incumbent Jones lead the team to success in the brutal NFC East? Our expert analysis dives deep into the Giants’ betting prospects, examining their strengths, weaknesses, and potential pitfalls to determine if the Giants are a smart bet or a sucker’s wager in the 2024 season.

New York Giants Schedule 2024

How Many Games Will The Giants Win This Season?

Giants fans beware, our initial win total projections might not give the team the most attractive odds, with their projected win total slated at over 6 ½ wins at +115, showing that New York will need to work overly hard to make it out of their initial rut and into the spotlight.

Besides their annual home and away games against the Dallas Cowboys, Philadelphia Eagles and Washington Commanders, their NFC East foes, at home in MetLife, the Giants will be facing the Baltimore Ravens, Cincinnati Bengals, Indianapolis Colts, Minnesota Vikings, New Orleans Saints, and Tampa Bay Buccaneers.

On the road, New York will face the Atlanta Falcons, Carolina Panthers, Cleveland Browns, Pittsburgh Steelers and Seattle Seahawks.

Should You Pick The Giants To Win The NFC East?

With the team’s opening odds at +1100 to win the NFC East title, leaving the Giants at dead last in their divisional race, oddsmakers are not sold on New York looking like a safe pick for this coming season.

Betting On A Giants Playoff Run? Here Are The Odds

Considering the growing level of competition within the NFC East and the NFC itself to snag up a spot in this season’s future playoff scene, the Giants are not looking like the sharpest bet with their odds to make it to the postseason slated at +400, while their odds to miss out on the playoffs at -600.

Can The Giants Make A Run For The NFC Crown?

With the odds to win the NFC crown slated at +6500, the Giants are looking like one of the longest long shot bets this season to win their respective conference title, only beating out the Panthers in the race for bottom dwellers in the NFC title race.

New York Giants
Atlanta Falcons
+10 -110
Point Spread
-10 -110
+333
Moneyline
-425
O 41 -110
Total
U 41 -110

How Safe Is Betting On The Giants To Win Super Bowl LXI?

Just like with their odds to win the NFC crown, oddsmakers are showing that New York’s chances to make it to Super Bowl LXI and win it are a long way from being a safe bet to come out as title winners. With +12500 odds, betting on the Giants to score a new Lombardi Trophy might offer the biggest payout, especially considering the minimal level of possibilities of said event happening.

What’s In Store For The Giants In 2024/25?

Coming into the season, the Giants present a complex picture for 2024. They have the potential to surprise and outperform expectations, especially with how the odds are stacked against them due to Barkley’s departure.

However, significant challenges remain, including Jones’ inconsistency and the strength of the NFC East. Ultimately, whether the Giants are a trap bet depends on your risk tolerance and belief in their ability to overcome adversity.

Our analysis suggests caution is warranted, but if the stars align, the Giants could be a dark horse worth backing.

Featured Picks

Featured News

2025 NFL Mock Draft 3.0: Besides Ward to Tennessee, Could We Be In for a Shock?

The Clock Is Ticking After months of speculation, and NFL news blowing up left and right with guesses and predictions on which team will pick who will come Thursday night, the time has come to drop... Read Now
nflNFL