Avalanche vs Maple Leafs NHL Same Game Parlay Picks: Bet Over, MacKinnon 2+ Points on March 19

It’s a bit of strange scheduling with the two regular-season meetings between Stanley Cup contenders coming less than two weeks apart in March. Colorado is listed by the BetUS sportsbook as the road favorite against the Maple Leafs for the first time since 2001.

Colorado outscored Toronto 4-0 in the third period en route to victory on March 8 as the home favorite. The game had no trouble landing over the total. Keep that in mind regarding the best options in the March 13 Panthers vs Maple Leafs parlay with the total set at 6.

The Avalanche vs Maple Leafs betting lines has Colorado priced at -204 to cover as a 1.5-goal favorite with -115 odds to win outright. Toronto is at +105 to come away with the victory on Wednesday.

Avalanche vs Maple Leafs How to Watch

• Game: Colorado Avalanche (41-24-3) vs Toronto Maple Leafs (40-24-3)
• Date/Time: March 19, 7 p.m. ET
• Location: Scotiabank Arena, Toronto
• Avalanche vs Maple Leafs Live Stream: NHL.tv

Avalanche vs Maple Leafs Free NHL Parlay Picks

• Leg 1: Avalanche vs Maple Leafs Over 6 (-120)

The Avalanche vs Maple Leafs games in Denver tend to be higher-scoring affairs than the ones in Toronto. However, since the start of February, these are two of the seven teams to average more than 3.5 goals per game.

The sports betting odds total is at 6 after the previous four meetings all had the total set at 6.5. With all the star power hitting the ice at Scotiabank Arena, it might not be the best night to be a goaltender.

Just two of the last 14 games between Colorado and Toronto landed under the total. We aren’t expecting to see that NHL trend to change. Bet the over.

Bet on Avalanche vs Maple Leafs Over 6 (-120)

• Leg 2: Maple Leafs +1.5 (-240)

The Toronto Maple Leafs have seen six of its last 10 games decided by one goal. If not for an empty-net goal with less than 10 seconds remaining in Saturday’s loss to Ottawa, that number would be even higher.

Old and new Maple Leafs must be better to close out Avalanche in highly anticipated rematch, from @sunhornbyhttps://t.co/5bG3N5J38K pic.twitter.com/8IhSeukjGi

— Toronto Sun (@TheTorontoSun) March 18, 2025

This a high-profile game between teams fighting for playoff positioning. When making NHL picks, don’t be surprised to see the teams traded scoring chances and goals. Take Toronto +1.5 goals.

Bet on Maple Leafs +1.5 (-240)

• Leg 3: Nathan MacKinnon 2+ Points (+114)

Our top NHL player prop pick for the Avalanche vs Maple Leafs game is Nathan MacKinnon to record 2+ points.

MacKinnon leads the NHL with 103 points. However, he has no goals and one assist over his last three games.

MacKinnon scored twice in the win over Toronto on March 8 and is due for a big game.

Bet on Nathan MacKinnon 2+ Points (+114)

• Leg 4: Auston Matthews Anytime Goal Scorer (Ev)

It seems hard to believe that Auston Matthews hasn’t had goals in at least three consecutive games in nearly two months.

Auston Dublin down! 🟢 pic.twitter.com/gSW6BX6p2e

— Toronto Maple Leafs (@MapleLeafs) March 18, 2025

Matthews has three goals and seven shots on goal over the last two games. While he didn’t score a goal the last time that Toronto faced Colorado, he had three assists. Bet on Matthews to light the lamp against the Rockies.

Bet on Auston Matthews Anytime Goal Scorer (Ev)

Odds and information are accurate at the time of writing. Please check with official sources for the latest updates before placing any bets

Question Of The Day