Contents

Maple Leafs vs Panthers NHL Same Game Parlay Picks for May 11: Take Florida (-185) to Win Game 4

Jim Fuller

· May 11 - 4 minutes read

Go with Florida (-185) to win in your Maple Leafs vs Panthers picks.
Bet on Florida’s Sam Reinhart to have at least one point (-197).
Make bank with our top NHL Picks Today! Join with our promo code HUDDLE125.

Parlay Picks

Odds

Sam Reinhart 1+ Points

(-197)

Mitchell Marner 1+ Goals

(+275)

Florida Panthers Moneyline

(-185)

Maple Leafs vs Panthers Under 6

(-105)

Bet These Parlay Picks At BetUS Sportsbook!

Maple Leafs vs Panthers NHL Same Game Parlay Picks for May 11: Take Florida (-185) to Win Game 4 — Washington Capitals center Dylan Strome (17) | Amber Searls-Imagn Images

The reigning Stanley Cup champion Florida Panthers played with fire to take Game 3 of their series with the Toronto Maple Leafs. Toronto forwards Auston Matthews, William Nylander and Matthew Knies all had chances to give the Maple Leafs the win in overtime before perennial Maple Leafs tormentor Brad Marchand scored to give the Panthers a much-needed win. Now the Panthers look to win again on Sunday and even the series.

The NHL betting odds have the Panthers priced at -185 to win Game 4. Toronto comes in at +159 to take a 3-1 series lead.

The NHL futures bets have Florida at +550 and Toronto at +650 in the odds of winning the Stanley Cup. Let’s check out some bets you should be making for Game 4 in the Maple Leafs vs Panthers series.

Panthers vs Maple Leafs Prediction

The Panthers didn’t reach back-to-back Stanley Cup Finals without being able to win tight games. That will to win was on display in Game 3, as Florida erased 2-0 and 3-1 deficits to get the win. Florida was +20 in hits and outshot Toronto 36-31. Those who bet on the NHL should look at Florida to win outright. However, tread carefully before taking Florida at +140 on the -1.5 puckline. Score prediction: Panthers 3, Maple Leafs 2.

Maple Leafs vs Panthers Free NHL Parlay Picks

Panthers C Sam Reinhart 1+ Points (-197)

Reinhart has seven multi-point games in the playoffs over the last three seasons after recording a goal and an assist in Game 3. He led the Panthers with six shots on goal after being held without a point in the first two games of the series.

“I think it’s little moments throughout a series that tilt it one way or another.”

Sam Reinhart joins @sportsnetkyle after a big overtime win for the Panthers in Game 3. pic.twitter.com/md052dxibm

— Sportsnet (@Sportsnet) May 10, 2025

When looking at the options for NHL parlay picks, the -197 odds for Reinhart to have 1+ points are worth considering.

Bet On Sam Reinhart 1+ Points (-197)

Maple Leafs F Mitchell Marner 1+ Goals (+275)

It is hard to believe that Mitchell Marner didn’t have a shot on goal despite playing nearly 26 minutes in Game 3. He did have two assists in the game to give him four points in the first three games of the series. Marner did make NHL news with a goal in one of the two road games in the regular season against the Panthers. Take a look at the +275 odds for Marner to have 1+ goals as you’re making your picks.

Bet On Mitchell Marner 1+ Goals (+275)

Florida Panthers Moneyline (-185)

Florida did it again with a key win in Game 3. Can the Panthers build on that momentum in Game 4? When considering NHL betting trends, it is worth noting that Florida’s star players came through as Aleksander Barkov, Reinhart, Carter Verhaeghe and Marchand combined for four goals and two assists with 14 shots on goal in Game 3.

Never thought we’d see the day where Roberto Luongo celebrates a Brad Marchand overtime winner pic.twitter.com/ADlOpvXuv0

— Sportsnet (@Sportsnet) May 10, 2025

Look for more of the same on Sunday night and take the Panthers to win when making your NHL predictions.

Bet on Carolina Panthers ML (-180)

Maple Leafs vs Panthers Under 6 (-105)

There was plenty of action in Game 3, with six goals scored before the midway point of the second period. Josh Gadjovich’s first goal of the playoffs with 4:53 left in the second period sent one of the more exciting NHL games this postseason over the total. Each of the first three games in the series went over the total. But I like that to change in Game 4, as both teams will look to tighten things up.

Bet on Panthers vs Maple Leafs Under 6 (-105)