Panthers vs Maple Leafs NHL Same Game Parlay Picks for Wednesday, May 14: Bet Toronto ATS to Bounce Back

The momentum has shifted for the Florida Panthers heading back to Toronto. But we’re not buying the NHL betting odds as we see Toronto as the better team. Yes, the Panthers all but neutralized Toronto in Game 4. But let’s not forget how much better Toronto was in the first two games. Coached by a Stanley Cup winner and boasting some clutch playmakers, bank on Toronto for this same-game NHL parlay.

“So much has changed, except the biggest thing.”@JDBunkis highlights the lack of production from Auston Matthews and Mitch Marner in the 2025 playoffs. #LeafsForever

🎧 https://t.co/ET2culOpbD pic.twitter.com/FqtPiYqwYk

— Sportsnet 590 The FAN (@FAN590) May 12, 2025

Panthers vs Maple Leafs Free NHL Parlay Picks

• Leg 1: Toronto Maple Leafs +1.5 (-220)

This is not the same Maple Leafs team that was the perennial butt of jokes for their early playoff exits. Yes, their stars are struggling to score. But Toronto is getting sound defensive work and netminding. Hence, parlaying Toronto +1.5 against the puck line is a solid NHL prediction here.

Florida’s 2-0 win over Toronto is only the second NHL game where the Leafs lost by two or more goals in these playoffs. And we can chalk up a list of many reasons, from uncalled penalties to Sergei Bobrovsky starting to get hot. But at the least, we expect Toronto to play Florida close at home and to win. For this parlay, go with the puck line.

Bet on Maple Leafs +1.5 (-210)

• Leg 2: Panthers vs Maple Leafs Under 6 Goals (-120)

The first three games saw high scoring and average totals of 8.3 goals. So Game 4 saw some overcorrection, though we see this as the start of low scores. Bobrovsky is starting to find his form, while Joseph Woll has not given up more than three goals in seven of his last eight starts. Anthony Stolarz is unlikely to play, per NHL news. Parlay the under.

#LeafsForever William Nylander leads the NHL in goals in team victories pic.twitter.com/xVCH1C2UAO

— Sportsnet Stats (@SNstats) May 9, 2025

Bet on Panthers vs Maple Leafs Under 6 (-120)

• Leg 3: William Nylander Over 0.5 Points (-218)

With Auston Matthews and Mitchell Marner going cold, the onus is on William Nylander to score. The Swede has had a knack for being clutch for Toronto, especially against Florida. He’s scored in six of Toronto’s last seven playoff games against Florida and has nine points in this span. This is one of the best NHL props today for a parlay.

Bet on William Nylander Over 0.5 Points (-218)

• Leg 4: Mitchell Marner Over 1.5 Shots on Goal (-141)

Mitchell Marner will need to be more aggressive and contribute more offensively if Toronto is to realize these lofty NHL futures bets. He’s been held without a shot on goal in the last two games. That figures to change as he averaged 1.6 and has had two or more in four of the last five games before that. Parlay his SOG to go over.

Bet on Mitchell Marner Over 1.5 Shots on Goal (-141)

Panthers vs Maple Leafs How to Watch

• Game: Florida Panthers (53-34-4) vs Toronto Maple Leafs (58-28-6)
• Date/Time: Wednesday, May 14, 7:00 p.m. ET
• Location: Scotiabank Arena, Toronto, ON
• Panthers vs Leafs Live Stream: NHL.tv

Get updated Panthers vs Maple Leafs injuries here.

Question Of The Day

Odds and information are accurate at the time of writing. Please check with official sources for the latest updates before placing any bets